Hall of Fame Rankings - Baseball Evaluation

Best Ever Rankings
for all Teams in History
for both seasons and
careers! All in one place!

Try Us Out
Stat Geek Baseball,
the Best Ever Book

2012 Paperback
Amazon.com
Barnes and Noble

2012 Ebook

Hall of Fame Ranks

Infielders/Catchers
Outfielders/DH/Others
Pitchers

What is PEVA?

PEVA is the acronym for Stat Geek Baseball's New Player Rating value. This grade is given to each player and pitcher each season, rating their performance on a peer to peer review. Six components for pitchers and batters are melded together into the PEVA Rating, which ranges each year from 0.200 to 64.000. For more information on PEVA and the other new baseballevaluation.com Stats, see our Definitions page. PEVA ratings are available for every pitcher and hitter in baseball history.

PEVA Player
Rating BOXSCORE

32.000 - Fantastic
(MVP/Cy Young Award Canddiate)
20.000 - Great (All League)
15.000 - Very Good (All Star Caliber)
10.000 - Good (Plus Starter)
3.500 - Average Player

Stat Geek Baseball Pages

Best Ever Lists
Best Position Players Ever
Best Pitchers Ever

Fantasy Baseball 2011
Fantasy Baseball Rankings
FB Rankings RAVE

Homepage
2010 Free Agents

Support This Site

Want More History, then Check out of Friends at
America's Best History,
where you get the ABH Timeline of Historic Events and Historic Site Pages from America's Best National Parks and Historic Sites.

Home

About Our Stats

All-Time Player Ratings

Buy Stat Geek Baseball

Sitemap

Baseball Evaluation

Hall of Fame Rankings

Career 1871-2011 (Regular Season)

Total PEVA for Position Players and Pitchers

First Base

Rank	First Name	Last Name	TOTAL PEVA	Yrs.	PEVA-T Per Year	HR	RBI	Ave.	W	SV	ERA
1	Lou	Gehrig	479.522	17	28.207	493	1995	0.340
2	Cap	Anson	432.886	27	16.033	97	2076	0.333	0	1	4.50
3	Jimmie	Foxx	359.936	20	17.997	534	1922	0.325	1	0	1.52
4	Dan	Brouthers	348.085	19	18.320	106	1296	0.342	0	0	7.83
5	Roger	Connor	336.978	18	18.721	138	1322	0.317
6	Eddie	Murray	324.361	21	15.446	504	1917	0.287
7	Harmon	Killebrew	270.652	22	12.302	573	1584	0.256
8	Willie	McCovey	261.038	22	11.865	521	1555	0.270
9	Willie	Stargell	241.847	21	11.517	475	1540	0.282
10	Tony	Perez	215.659	23	9.376	379	1652	0.279
11	Hank	Greenberg	215.163	13	16.551	331	1276	0.313
12	Jake	Beckley	213.234	20	10.662	86	1575	0.308	0	0	6.75
13	Orlando	Cepeda	209.487	17	12.323	379	1365	0.297
14	George	Sisler	197.119	15	13.141	102	1175	0.340	5	3	2.35
15	Johnny	Mize	191.547	15	12.770	359	1337	0.312
16	Bill	Terry	157.226	14	11.230	154	1078	0.341
17	Jim	Bottomley	145.525	16	9.095	219	1422	0.310
18	Frank	Chance	108.846	17	6.403	20	596	0.296
19	George	Kelly	93.677	16	5.855	148	1020	0.297	1	0	0.00

Second Base

Rank	First	Last Name	TOTAL PEVA	Yrs.	PEVA-T PerYr.	HR	RBI	Ave.
1	Rogers	Hornsby	361.117	23	15.701	301	1584	0.358
2	Eddie	Collins	349.132	25	13.965	47	1300	0.333
3	Nap	Lajoie	337.934	21	16.092	83	1599	0.338
4	Joe	Morgan	287.830	22	13.083	268	1133	0.271
5	Charlie	Gehringer	233.202	19	12.274	184	1427	0.320
6	Rod	Carew	208.083	19	10.952	92	1015	0.328
7	Roberto	Alomar	184.493	17	10.853	210	1134	0.300
8	Ryne	Sandberg	177.295	16	11.081	282	1061	0.285
9	Bid	McPhee	166.066	18	9.226	53	1067	0.271
10	Bobby	Doerr	157.073	14	11.219	223	1247	0.288
11	Nellie	Fox	155.463	19	8.182	35	790	0.288
12	Jackie	Robinson	146.209	10	14.621	137	734	0.311
13	Frankie	Frisch	141.796	19	7.463	105	1244	0.316
14	Red	Schoendienst	131.155	19	6.903	84	773	0.289
15	Billy	Herman	131.084	15	8.739	47	839	0.304
16	Joe	Gordon	127.893	11	11.627	253	975	0.268
17	Tony	Lazzeri	126.796	14	9.057	178	1191	0.292
18	Johnny	Evers	102.257	18	5.681	12	538	0.270
19	Bill	Mazeroski	98.836	17	5.814	138	853	0.260

TeePossible Tees, T-Shirts for Fun, for Sports, for History

Get Great Archive Prints from Baseball Evaluation and Teepossible.com. Makes a Great Gift for the Baseball Fan
in Your Life.

Now @ Teepossible Zazzle

Third Base

Rank	First Name	Last Name	TOTAL PEVA	Yrs.	PEVA-T Per Year	HR	RBI	Ave.	W	SV	ERA
1	Mike	Schmidt	383.574	18	21.310	548	1595	0.267
2	Eddie	Mathews	360.187	17	21.187	512	1453	0.271
3	George	Brett	301.897	21	14.376	317	1595	0.305
4	Wade	Boggs	293.035	18	16.280	118	1014	0.328	0	0	3.86
5	Ron	Santo	259.712	15	17.314	342	1331	0.277
6	Brooks	Robinson	232.881	23	10.125	268	1357	0.267
7	Frank	Baker	204.500	13	15.731	96	987	0.307
8	Jimmy	Collins	167.223	14	11.944	65	983	0.294
9	Pie	Traynor	141.423	17	8.319	58	1273	0.320
10	George	Kell	134.828	15	8.989	78	870	0.306
11	Freddie	Lindstrom	95.076	13	7.314	103	779	0.311

Shortstop

Rank	First Name	Last Name	TOTAL PEVA	Yrs.	PEVA-T Per Year	HR	RBI	Ave.	W	SV	ERA
1	Honus	Wagner	451.472	21	21.499	101	1732	0.327	0	0	0.00
2	Cal	Ripken	320.188	21	15.247	431	1695	0.276
3	Robin	Yount	291.976	20	14.599	251	1406	0.285
4	Ernie	Banks	264.788	19	13.936	512	1636	0.274
5	George	Davis	245.441	20	12.272	73	1437	0.295	0	1	15.75
6	John	Ward	212.855	17	12.521	26	867	0.275	164	3	2.10
7	Luke	Appling	210.671	20	10.534	45	1116	0.310
8	Joe	Cronin	196.868	20	9.843	170	1424	0.301
9	Arky	Vaughan	191.281	14	13.663	96	926	0.318
10	Bobby	Wallace	186.535	25	7.461	34	1121	0.268	24	1	3.87
11	Lou	Boudreau	168.772	15	11.251	68	789	0.295
12	Pee	Wee Reese	166.690	16	10.418	126	885	0.269
13	Barry	Larkin	165.994	19	8.737	198	960	0.295
14	Ozzie	Smith	162.052	19	8.529	28	793	0.262
15	Joe	Sewell	159.048	14	11.361	49	1055	0.312
16	Luis	Aparicio	156.787	18	8.710	83	791	0.262
17	Hughie	Jennings	152.306	17	8.959	18	840	0.311
18	Rabbit	Maranville	148.551	23	6.459	28	884	0.258
19	Dave	Bancroft	122.761	16	7.673	32	591	0.279
20	Joe	Tinker	119.627	15	7.975	31	782	0.262
21	Phil	Rizzuto	111.989	13	8.615	38	563	0.273
22	Travis	Jackson	98.655	15	6.577	135	929	0.291

Catcher

Rank	First Name	Last Name	TOTAL PEVA	Yrs.	PEVA-T Per Year	HR	RBI	Ave.	W	SV	ERA
1	Johnny	Bench	256.662	17	15.098	389	1376	0.267
2	Yogi	Berra	251.624	19	13.243	358	1430	0.285
3	Gary	Carter	233.612	19	12.295	324	1225	0.262
4	Carlton	Fisk	214.953	24	8.956	376	1330	0.269
5	Bill	Dickey	202.680	17	11.922	202	1209	0.313
6	Mickey	Cochrane	173.444	13	13.342	119	832	0.320
7	Roy	Campanella	162.658	10	16.266	242	856	0.276
8	Gabby	Hartnett	155.361	20	7.768	236	1179	0.297
9	Buck	Ewing	146.265	18	8.126	71	883	0.303	2	0	3.45
10	Ernie	Lombardi	126.894	17	7.464	190	990	0.306
11	Roger	Bresnahan	120.459	17	7.086	26	530	0.279	4	0	3.93
12	Rick	Ferrell	109.810	18	6.101	28	734	0.281
13	Ray	Schalk	102.242	18	5.680	11	594	0.253

Note: PEVA-T equals Total PEVA for Career, including both batting and pitching PEVA. All HOF Members Listed above 50 Total PEVA.
More Hall of Fame Ranks Infielders/Catchers Outfielders/DH/Others Pitchers

Al Spalding

Ross Barnes

Johan Santana

Babe Ruth

Cy Young

Shibe Park, Philadelphia, baseballevaluation.com

Photo Credits: Cristy Mathewsom, Walter Johnson (LOC). Bottom: Grover Cleveland Alexander (LOC); Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig (Wikipedia Commons); Eddie Collins (LOC); Rickey Henderson (Wikipedia Commons); Frank Baker (LOC).

Baseball Evaluation and all materials on this site are the 2012 Copyright and intellectual property of JDP ECON and their licensors. All worldwide rights reserved. The Baseball Evaluation system was developed independently of Major League Baseball and the Major League Baseball Players Association and is not endorsed by or associated in any way with either organization.

Note: All Baseball Evaluation Stats were developed by JDP Econ & are the proprietary property of JDP ECON. All rights reserved. If Baseball Evaluation stats are used in articles, etc., please credit baseballevalution.com.

Free template by Interspire